Open Access
Head-to-head comparison between the EQ-5D-5L and the EQ-5D-3L in general population health surveys
(BioMed Central, 2018) Martí Pastor, Marc; Pont, Angels; Ávila, Mónica; Garin, Olatz; Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Economía; Ekonomia
Background: The EQ-5D has been frequently used in national health surveys. This study is a head-to-head comparison to assess how expanding the number of levels from three (EQ-5D-3L) to five in the new EQ-5D-5L version has improved its distribution, discriminatory power, and validity in the general population. Methods: A representative sample (N = 7554) from the Catalan Health Interview Survey 2011–2012, aged ≥18, answered both EQ-5D versions, and we evaluated the response redistribution and inconsistencies between them. To assess validity of this redistribution, we calculated the mean of the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), which measures perceived health. The discriminatory power was examined with Shannon Indices, calculated for each dimension separately. Spanish preference value sets were applied to obtain utility indices, examining their distribution with statistics of central tendency and dispersion. We estimated the proportion of individuals reporting the best health state in EQ-5D-5L and EQ-5D-3L within groups of specific chronic conditions and their VAS mean. Results: A very small reduction in the percentage of individuals with the best health state was observed, from 61.8% in EQ-5D-3L to 60.8% in EQ-5D-5L. In contrast, a large proportion of individuals reporting extreme problems in the 3 L version moved to severe problems (level 4) in the 5 L version, particularly for pain/discomfort (75.5%) and anxiety/depression (66.4%). The average proportion of inconsistencies was 0.9%. The pattern of the perceived health VAS mean confirmed the hypothesis established a priori, supporting the validity of the observed redistribution. Shannon index showed that absolute informativity was higher in the 5 L version for all dimensions. The means (SD) of the Spanish EQ-5D-3L and EQ-5D-5L indices were 0.87 (0.25) and 0.89 (0.22). The proportion of individuals with the best health state within each specific chronic condition was very similar, regardless of the EQ-5D version (≤ 30% in half of the 28 chronic conditions). Conclusion: Although the proportion of individuals with the best possible health state is still very high, our findings support that the increase of levels provided by the EQ-5D-5L contributed to the validity and discriminatory power of this new version to measure health in general population, as in the national health surveys.
Open Access
Incentives when altruism is impure: the case of blood and living organ donations
(2013) Errea Rodríguez, María; Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Economía; Ekonomia
The decision to donate blood and living organs is considered voluntary and altruistic. However, the shortage of donors has opened an interesting debate in recent years, considering offering economic incentives to donors. This paper analyzes theoretically and empirically, the effects of incentives over individuals when facing the decision of becoming donors. Results show that crowding-in of blood donors would be more likely by offering 'Information concerning blood donations' or 'Blood Tests'. In both, blood and living organ donations, 'Money' would be very likely to crowd-out individuals from donating. Concerning living organs, we do not find good evidence for crowding-in. We conclude donation policies, properly designed, could help to increase the number of donors, and more specifically suggest implementing non-monetary incentives.
Open Access
La financiación sanitaria autonómica. Bases para una propuesta
(1998) Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Economía; Ekonomia
Se analizan las novedades recientes en el debate sobre financiación territorial sanitaria: el nuevo modelo de financiación autonómica para el quinquenio 1997-2001, y la nueva RAWP, fórmula inglesa de reparto financiero sanitario y el acuerdo del Consejo de Polí’tica Fiscal y Financiera de 27 de Noviembre de 1997 estableciendo un mecanismo de financiación de la sanidad de la Seguridad Social para el cuatrienio 1998-2001. La discusión sobre financiación auton—çomica de la sanidad es un asunto donde el consenso deviene crucial, y éste ha de empezar por un acuerdo de principio ético. Consideramos que el principio es la igualdad de oportunidades. Nuestra propuesta consiste en profundizar en la corresponsabilidad fiscal incorporando la sanidad a la financiación autonómica general. En este nuevo marco, habrá que diseñar los mecanismos de garantí’a que permitan el logro de los objetivos de la Ley General de Sanidad. Quedan, así’, establecidas, las bases para una agenda de trabajo para elaborar el acuerdo del año 2001.
Open Access
An economic model of behaviour: attitudes towards altruistic blood and organ donations
(2009) Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Errea Rodríguez, María; Economía; Ekonomia
The aim of this research is to model altruistic blood and organ donors behaviour. First, we make an analysis of the decision of to be or not to be a donor for any individual. We propose a model where individuals compare the expected utility of deciding to become a donor, with the utility of the alternative decision (not to become a donor). Second, we continue with the identification of the variables having influence over this decision, the expected effects of such a donation (positive and negative) and the importance of the expectations over individuals well-being and the subsequent decision. We work with rational individuals that behave altruistically when making a decision. The model is specific because the goods we consider can only cover vital needs. We posed hypothesis about some variables for each kind of the donations considered (blood and organ donations). This hypothesis can be useful to identify which are the variables having influence actually over this decision. We propose a pilot survey to test our model. First results from a university students survey show the relevant variables influencing blood an organ donations, and seem to confirm the model.
Open Access
Actividad física y salud autopercibida en personas mayores de 50 años
(Universidad Autonoma de Madrid, 2017) Lera López, Fernando; Garrués Irisarri, Mirian; Ollo López, Andrea; Sánchez Iriso, Eduardo; Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Sánchez-Santos, José Manuel; Economía; Ekonomia; Gestión de Empresas; Enpresen Kudeaketa
El propósito del estudio es analizar los posibles efectos de la actividad física sobre la salud autopercibida. Para ello, se encuestó a 765 personas entre 50-70 años durante 2012 en España. Se utilizó el cuestionario internacional de actividad física (IPAQ) para estimar el equivalente metabólico de la tarea (MET) total y en cuatro ámbitos: trabajo, ocio, hogar y desplazamientos. La salud auto-percibida se obtuvo de la escala visual analógica del EQ-5D-5L. Los resultados muestran que únicamente el gasto energético de actividad física en el tiempo de ocio incide positivamente en el nivel de salud percibido, el resto de ámbitos no tienen influencia significativa. Asimismo, la autopercepción de la salud es más negativa con mayor edad, menor nivel educativo y mayor frecuencia de uso de servicios sanitarios. En conclusión, la actividad física desarrollada en el tiempo libre podría plantearse como alternativa para mejorar la calidad de vida de los mayores.
Open Access
Socio-demographic indicators of self-reported health based on EQ-5D-3L: a cross-country analysis of population surveys from 18 countries
(Frontiers Media, 2023) Szende, Agota; Janssen, Mathieu F.; Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Ramos Goñi, Juan Manuel; Burström, Kristina; Economía; Ekonomia
Background: Generic health-related quality of life instruments, such as the EQ-5D, are increasingly used by countries to monitor population health via general population health surveys. Our aim was to demonstrate analytic options to measure socio-demographic dierences in self-reported health using the EuroQol Group’s archive of EQ-5D-3L population surveys that accumulated over the past two decades. Methods: Analyses captured self-reported EQ-5D-3L data on over 100,000 individuals from 18 countries with nationally representative population surveys. Socio-demographic indicators employed were age, sex, educational level and income. Logistic regression odds ratios and the health concentration index methodology were used in the socio-demographic analysis of EQ-5D-3L data. Results: Statistically significant socio-demographic dierences existed in all countries (p < 0.01) with the EQ VAS based health concentration index varying from 0.090 to 0.157 across countries. Age had generally the largest contributing share, while educational level also had a consistent role in explaining lower levels of self-reported health. Further analysis in a subset of 7 countries with income data showed that, beyond educational level, income itself had an additional significant impact on self-reported health. Among the 5 dimensions of the EQ-5D-3L descriptive system, problems with usual activities and pain/discomfort had the largest contribution to the concentration of overall self-assessed health measured on the EQ VAS in most countries. Conclusion: The EQ-5D-3L was shown to be a powerful multi-dimensional instrument in the analyses of socio-demographic dierences in self-reported health using various analytic methods. It oered a unique insight of inequalities by health dimensions
Open Access
Attitudes towards blood and living organ donations
(2010) Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Errea Rodríguez, María; Economía; Ekonomia
We model the decision of whether or not to become a blood/living organ donor. The expected utility for becoming a donor is a function of the degree of altruism, the consumption of goods, the costs of donation, the very pleasure of giving, and the recipient’s utility associated to donation. Empirically, we observe differences in the expected costs and benefits from donation between blood and non-blood donors, and between individuals with different willingness to donate living organs. Looking at benefits/costs of donation through reasons for donating/not donating, we conclude policies to encourage donation should focus on raising awareness and provide information.
Open Access
A pilot inquiry on incentives and intrinsic motivation in health care: the motivational capital explained by doctors
(2014) Berdud García-López, Mikel; Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Nieto Vázquez, Jorge; Economía; Ekonomia
Where the contracts are incomplete, the resulting co-ordination problems may be attenuated if workers are intrinsically motivated to do the work. It is established by theoretical and empirical literature that workers within public organizations are intrinsically motivated to exert effort doing the job and have a strong sense of social agents with the mission of providing collective goods to citizens and tax payers. This paper is an empirical pilot study in the health care sector using methods of Qualitative Analysis research. We run semistructured interviews á-la-Bewley to sixteen physicians of Navarre’s health Care Servicio Navarro de Salud-Osasunbidea (SNS-O). The objective of the work is twofold: first, to find empirical evidence about doctors’ non-monetary motives and second, to find evidence about how these non-monetary motives shape doctors’ behavior. We formulate several testable hypotheses: (1) Doctors are intrinsically motivated agents, (2) Economic incentives and control policies may crowd-out intrinsic motivation and (3) Well designed incentives may crowd-in agents intrinsic motivation. Results confirm the hypotheses formulated above and coming from our theoretical findings [11], [12]. Finally, we also found empirical evidence of conflict between political advisors or health managers (principals) and physicians (agents). Results are a step forward in the optimal design of incentive schemes and policies which crowd in doctors’ intrinsic motivation.
Open Access
El EQ-5D como medida de resultados en salud
(Elsevier España, S.L.U., 2015) Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Economía; Ekonomia
El EQ-5D ha mostrado su validez y fiabilidad como medida de salud, pero su versión original presentaba algunas limitaciones, como efecto techo y escaso poder discriminatorio, especialmente en los cambios pequeños en los estados de salud más leves. Con objeto de superar estos problemas, el Grupo EuroQol lanzó la versión EQ-5D-5L en 2009, con la adición de dos niveles en cada una de las dimensiones (sin problemas, problemas leves, problemas moderados, problemas graves y problemas extremos/imposibilidad), lo que define un total de 3125 (5) estados de salud. El EQ-5D-5L ha mostrado ser una extensión válida del EQ-5D-3L que mejora las propiedades de medición, y ya se encuentra disponible en más de 120 idiomas. Existe también una versión juvenil, el EQ-5D-Y.
Open Access
Costs and effectiveness of a syringe distribution and needle exchange programme for HIV prevention in a regional setting
(2002) Cabasés Hita, Juan Manuel; Sánchez Iriso, Eduardo; Economía; Ekonomia
Objective: To estimate the costs and effectiveness of a HIV prevention intervention consisting of distribution of an anti-Aids kit and needle exchange, in operation since 1993 in Navarra, Spain. Methods: Total costs of the programme, namely production, storage and distribution as well as management, are estimated getting a cost figure per sterile syringe distributed. Effectiveness, defined as the number of averted HIV infections among IDUs due to their injecting behaviour, is estimated as a function of the level of coverage of the programme, using a mathematical model. Results: The estimated number of averted HIV infections ranged from 7.59 (in 1995) to 1.23 (in 2000). Yearly incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICER) ranged from 8.331 (in 1994) to 44.287 (in 2000) euro per HIV infection averted. With estimated health care costs of treatment of an HIV infection of 99.371 euro, the programme has been cost saving along the whole period considered. One way sensitivity analysis for 5 uncertain parameters was performed. These were the number of active IDUs in the region, number of annual injections among IDUs with non sterile syringes, percentage of lost and unused syringes of the total provided, probability of HIV infection due to injecting behaviour, and life expectancy of HIV+ persons. The results confirm our findings. We conclude the programme has been cost saving from the health care system perspective.